Comparison
Stamped vs Yotpo
Stamped vs Yotpo for Shopify reviews + loyalty: a cheaper bundled suite vs the integrated category leader — pricing, depth and who each fits.
Stamped
Reviews and loyalty for ecommerce brands.
Yotpo
"Loyalty, Reviews & AI Visibility For Ecommerce" — eCommerce retention marketing platform.
Affiliate link. Pricing and terms are set by the vendor. details
On this page
At a glance
Stamped and Yotpo both bundle reviews and loyalty for Shopify, competing directly on the same retention surface. Yotpo is the integrated category leader with the deepest ecosystem; Stamped positions as the value bundle — similar scope at roughly a sixth of Yotpo's cost per one reviewer. The split is polish and ecosystem vs price.
Quick stats
Starting price
Stamped
$199/mo
Yotpo
$79/mo
Rating
Stamped
8.3/10
Yotpo
8.3/10
Integrations
Stamped
8
Yotpo
8
Pricing
Stamped
$199/mo
- up to
- $798/mo
- Model
- tiered
Tiers (verified 2026-04): Monthly-order based: Reviews $199/mo, Full Suite (multi-product, reviews + loyalty) $798/mo, Enterprise custom ($1M+ rev). Pricing gotchas: Priced by monthly order volume; free plan removed in 2025; additional domains $100/mo each; no overage fees since 2025. Free plan: No — self-serve Shopify plans for smaller brands, no traditional free trial. Verified 2026-04
Yotpo
$79/mo
- up to
- —
- Model
- custom
Tiers: Reviews: Free (50 orders), Starter $79/mo (500 orders), Pro $169/mo, Premium custom; Loyalty: Free, Pro $199/mo, Premium custom; Bundle Pro $368/mo for both; Premium tier $799-$1,202/mo at 3K orders Pricing gotchas: Each module billed separately (Reviews + Loyalty stacked = $278+/mo minimum); SMS and Email products discontinued — Reviews and Loyalty only. Free plan: Yes—Free Reviews (50 orders/mo) and Free Loyalty (basic tier) Verified 2026-05-30
Yotpo starts at $79/mo vs Stamped's $199/mo. At the top tier Stamped climbs to $798/mo. Pricing models differ: Stamped is tiered, Yotpo is custom.
Features
Stamped
- In-email review collection (photo/video)
- Google Shopping syndication
- Loyalty points / VIP tiers / referrals
- Lifecycle automation / replenishment
- Questions & Answers
- AI sentiment analysis
Yotpo
- Cross-Product Data Sharing — Loyalty and reviews data flow between products in one platform
- Multi-Platform Support — Reviews and Loyalty work on Shopify, BigCommerce, Adobe Commerce, Salesforce
- Reviews Syndication — Distribute reviews to Google Shopping, Meta, TikTok, Target, Macy's
- Smart Review Prompts — Prompts customers to rate specific attributes (fit, style, comfort)
- Loyalty VIP Tiers — Spending-based tier system with custom rewards
- Photo / Video / UGC Reviews — Visual reviews supported alongside text
Shopify integration
Stamped
Native Shopify build; integrates with the retention stack (Klaviyo, Attentive, Gorgias, Recharge, Postscript). Positioned as a cheaper Yotpo alternative for reviews + loyalty.
Yotpo
Deep native Shopify integration; Shopify App Store; Shopify Plus Technology Partner; one-click install; native to Shopify POS
Integrations
Only Stamped
- Attentive
- Bazaarvoice (Syndication)
- Gorgias
- Klaviyo
- Postscript
- Recharge
- Shop App
- Tapcart
Both
No data yet
Only Yotpo
- AdRoll
- Listrak
- Meta
- Nosto
- Shopify
- Shopify POS
- Zendesk
Customer support
Support rating (aggregated from independent review platforms like G2, Capterra, Shopify App Store): Stamped 9/10, Yotpo 8.8/10. This is an editorial composite of channel availability, response speed, and resolution quality — see the individual reviews below for specifics.
Pros & cons
Stamped
Pros
- Unified reviews + loyalty
- Best-in-class in-email review collection
- Cheaper than Yotpo with strong support
Cons
- Glitchy UI / automation editor
- Product feels static
- Slow ticket-based support (no live chat)
Yotpo
Pros
- All-in-one: reviews + loyalty + UGC + syndication (post-sunset focus)
- Strong UGC moderation & retailer syndication
- Shopify Plus partnership
Cons
- Pricing perceived as expensive ($12K–$30K/yr actual)
- Yotpo sunset SMS & Email products December 31, 2025 — major trust hit, with ~34% staff cut
- Support quality declines after onboarding
When each one wins
Winner: Yotpo
Integrated suite, budget allows
Yotpo's mature reviews + loyalty + SMS ecosystem is the polished default when cost isn't the constraint.
Winner: Stamped
Reviews + loyalty on a budget
Stamped bundles both at a fraction of Yotpo's cost, with best-in-class in-email review collection.
Winner: Yotpo
Long-term polish and support
Yotpo's support depth and product maturity beat Stamped's ticket-only support and glitchy editor.
Our verdict
Yotpo is the integrated default when budget allows: reviews, loyalty, SMS and UGC in one mature, Shopify-native ecosystem, with the polish and support depth that justify the premium. Stamped counters on price — reviews + loyalty in one dashboard, best-in-class in-email review collection, and a cost that operators peg at a fraction of Yotpo's — but its UI and automation editor draw 'glitchy' complaints and support is ticket-only with no live chat. Pick Yotpo if you want the polished, integrated suite and can absorb the cost; pick Stamped if you want reviews + loyalty bundled at a lower price and can live with a rougher product. If reviews alone are the need, Loox (visual) or Judge.me (free) are cleaner single-purpose picks. For the full Yotpo pricing breakdown (post-sunset Reviews + Loyalty only, $278 bundle floor), see /pricing/yotpo.
Related comparisons
- BazaarvoicevsYotpo
For a Shopify store, Yotpo is the default: reviews, loyalty and UGC in one Shopify-native suite, with self-serve pricing and a free tier to start. Bazaarvoice only earns its six-figure, custom-quoted contract (~$184K/yr average) when review syndication to Walmart, Target and 2,300+ other retailers is a board-level priority — a need DTC-only brands don't have. Bazaarvoice's retail syndication network is genuinely best-in-class and nothing Shopify-native matches it, but its dated UI and rigid 12-month auto-renew contracts are consistent operator complaints. Pick Yotpo if you sell primarily through your own Shopify storefront; pick Bazaarvoice only if you distribute across many major retailers and need your UGC on product pages you don't own. For the full Yotpo pricing breakdown (post-sunset Reviews + Loyalty only, $278 bundle floor), see /pricing/yotpo.
Open
- LooxvsStamped
Loox is the pick if reviews — especially photo and video — are the job: it's the visual-reviews specialist on Shopify, clean to set up and run, with strong automated review requests and on-site galleries. Stamped does reviews too, plus loyalty in the same dashboard at a value price, which is appealing if you want both in one tool — but operators flag a glitchier UI and ticket-only support, and its reviews experience isn't as polished as Loox's focused one. Pick Loox if visual reviews are the priority and you'd rather a tool that does one thing well; pick Stamped if you specifically want reviews and loyalty bundled and can accept a rougher product to get them together. If you want a free reviews option, Judge.me is the budget default.
Open
- LooxvsYotpo
For sub-$1M ARR Shopify stores, Loox is the pragmatic pick — $9.99/mo entry, photo + video UGC widgets purpose-built for visual conversion, active affiliate program. Yotpo Reviews at $79/mo entry is over-engineered for this stage. For brands above $1M ARR where the enterprise-grade UGC moderation + Yotpo Loyalty bundle is the integrated need, Yotpo becomes evaluable — but explicitly verify that the post-SMS/Email-sunset organization can still deliver the support+roadmap your stage needs, given the ~34% staff cut. Both run affiliate programs. For the full Yotpo pricing breakdown (post-sunset Reviews + Loyalty only, $278 bundle floor), see /pricing/yotpo.
Open
- Judge.mevsYotpo
For sub-$1M ARR Shopify stores, Judge.me at $15/mo is the dominant pragmatic pick — readers should know we keep it catalogued without affiliate CTA. For brands above $1M ARR bundling Reviews + Loyalty as a single vendor case, Yotpo becomes evaluable, but explicitly verify the post-sunset organization (~34% staff cut following Aug 2025 announcement) can deliver the support tier you need before committing. Pure-play Yotpo Reviews at $79/mo without the Loyalty bundle is over-engineered for most stages — Judge.me handles text+photo reviews well enough that the 5x price premium needs an integrated-case justification. For the full Yotpo pricing breakdown (post-sunset Reviews + Loyalty only, $278 bundle floor), see /pricing/yotpo.
Open
